All martial artists have been curious about how long it takes to achieve a black belt, at least once at some point in time. Some ask the question openly, while others are hesitant.
But why the curiosity in the first place? And what do martial art instructors think about the question?
What You Will Learn
5 Reasons Why People Ask the Question
People want to know how long it takes to get a black belt for many reasons. Here are five…
1For bragging rights
Some people want the black belt as a status symbol. Their reward in getting a black belt is extrinsic.
Quite a few want to say they have a black belt.
2For a clearer goal setting timeline
For some, it puts training in perspective. Some need the motivation or the timeframe in order to set their goals.
3The need to know if they are progressing
Others are just curious about the progression and want to get fit but learn new material and feel they’re progressing too
4To avoid McDojos and Black-belt Mills
Supposedly, the shorter the time needed to get a black belt, the less credible the dojo is. Having quick black belt programs may suggest that the dojo prioritises profit over passing on a valuable skill.
Joelle explains her views.
From prior training as a teenager I had a rough idea of how rigorous it was going to be to even make it back to the equivalent rank I once was. I wanted to know if there was going to be pressure put on me to look as good as a Shodan in a mere 3 years.
Nope – the average is 8 to 10 years.
Somewhere along the line I picked up on the concepts of “McDojos” or “belt mills.” I was grateful I’d found an organization that doesn’t compromise the art and the beauty of the journey in order to make people happy by giving away belts.
Note: Different parts of the world uses different standards to award the first-degree black belt. In Asia, it is not unusual to get shodan within three years. That’s because, in general, a first-degree black belt has never been regarded anything more than a beginner.
Check out “How long does it take to get a black belt?” for a detailed explanation (and also the average time it takes to get a black belt in various martial arts). I will also be discussing the topic of quick black belt achievements in the last part of the series.
5Find out how quickly they can learn self-defense or fighting skills
Some people use the black-belt as an indication for mastery and effectiveness. In truth, they don’t really care about the belt as a status. Instead, they are concerned about the time needed to achieve an effective level of skill.
These people generally fall into two groups:
- People who are being bullied and need a a quick way to learn how to defend themselves.
- People looking to get into competitive fights as soon as possible.
So, why is it taboo to ask about the time it takes to get a black belt from the dojo…
Why is it taboo to ask the black belt question in some dojos?
When you ask your instructor (or a senior student) how long it takes to get your black belt, it makes them feel as though your priorities are not in the right place. It suggests that the belt is more important to you than the journey, and that you’d stop training once you reach the “end” – first-degree black belt.
That said, not all instructors get irritated by the question. It is usually instructors with traditional Asian values that don’t like being asked the time taken to get a black belt.
Understanding Dojos and Dojangs with Traditional Values
Here’s what the late Kensho Furuya wrote:
[…] And the most commonly asked question is, “How long does it take to get a black belt?” I don’t know how this question is answered in other schools, but my students know that asking such a question in my dojo would set them back several years in their training. It would be a disaster. […]
Train hard, be humble, don’t show off in front of your teacher or other students, don’t complain about any task and do your best in everything in your life.
Kensho Furuya was from a dojo steeped in traditional Japanese values.
Dojos like that follow certain cultural practices from the origin country of the martial art. For instance, all potential students need to meet the chief instructor before beginning to train. That instructor has the discretion of rejecting you for any reason.
Of course, there are a few good reasons to ask about the time needed to get a black belt. However, within a modern society that prizes quick results, ego-stroking and sloppy standards, you run a risk of creating a negative impression when you ask that.
Make sure to be tactful in how you frame that question if you intend to join a martial art that holds traditional values. For an insight on how being fixated on black belt can be counterproductive, read the following anecdote…
The Paradox of Mastery and Focus (Anecdote)
Many of you must have heard of this anecdote (adapted below), which explains how the fixation on mastery distracts a person from that goal:
A student once asked his martial art instructor earnestly, “If I’m devoted to studying your martial art, how long will it take me to master it?”
The instructor casually replied, “Ten years.”
The student was impatient and couldn’t accept that answer. He wanted to shorten the duration of study. He thus responded with another question, “But I will work very hard. I will practice everyday, ten or more hours a day if I have to. How long will it take then?”
The teacher thought for a moment, “Twenty years.”
Why did the time needed for mastery double (with obsessive focus)?
Because… the stubborn fixation to learn something quickly, makes you miss out tiny but crucial elements needed to master a martial art. You learn the form but miss the principles.
It’s no different than getting a distinction in your exams after receiving numerous hints on what questions will be tested on. You’ve memorised how to answer the questions in a preset format. But really have a superficial understanding of the topic. This simply means you won’t be able to apply the knowledge in real life.
And so, some instructors see the question (and overly obsessive desire for a black belt) as counterproductive.
What do other instructors think?
All of the instructors I’ve asked don’t mind the question. But a few have underlying concerns with the question. Surprisingly, others have raised valid points for students wanting to know the length of time needed to achieve first-degree black belt.
Instructors who don’t mind, but have some concerns
Jesse Enkamp (Karate by Jesse):
I feel like their priorities are off, but it doesn’t irritate me because these types of questions are expected if you’re a professional Karate instructor.
The dilemma is that Karate is not a result oriented activity, it’s a process oriented one. This due to its Oriental heritage and roots. For a Western practitioner, this might seem like a foreign concept at first. But once they learn to accept it, they might discover that the journey is actually the destination… the goal is the Way.
Ando Mierzwa (Sensei Ando):
I don’t get mad at a student for asking about belt ranks… I get angry at myself for not successfully shifting that student’s focus from extrinsic rewards to intrinsic rewards.
It’s natural for a beginner to ask about rank, because they don’t realize how much more martial arts training can offer them. The job of a teacher is to guide the beginner through experiences that are so exciting and fulfilling that questions about rank become unimportant. Not always easy to do, but that’s the goal!
The Concerns of Instructors Jesse and Ando
Both Jesse and Ando are fine with beginners asking the question. However, they still feel that it is a counterproductive attitude to hold when learning martial arts.
As Jesse best explained – within traditional martial arts, the journey is far more important than the end. In fact, the “end” is an illusion.
The end, is what I believe Ando refers to as the “intrinsic rewards” of martial art training.
Instructors who don’t mind at all
Andrea Harkins (The Martial Arts Woman):
I don’t mind it. It is a goal for many. I think it is a valid question.
If you go to college, you know how long it will take to get a degree. For some, it puts training in perspective. Some need the motivation or the timeframe in order to set their goals.
Dan Holloway (The Martial View & Defense Lab Lincoln):
Hey mate. It doesn’t annoy me as the black belt is very symbolic to a lot of people.
I usually tell people there isn’t a specific amount of time. It’s up to them and how hard they train and when they’re ready for it. And that black belt isn’t the end of the journey. It’s the beginning.
Bottomline: How should you approach this curious issue?
I personally feel that the question of “how long does it take to get black belt in your dojo?” is okay to ask. Most martial art instructors would expect it, and understand the curiosity.
However, be sure to not come off as someone who’s joining a martial art for the the wrong reasons. This is especially true for instructors who adopt traditional Asian values within traditional martial arts.
Also, even if you ask the question, it is likely you will get a vague but valid responses like:
- It depends
- As long as it takes
In fact, Dan’s response is most accurate – the time needed to get black belt depends on the student. You simply cannot take an average and expect yourself to fall within that range.
Nevertheless, if you really want to know how long it takes to get black belt, learn basic skills or master an entire martial art syllabus, check out the next section. You will at least get a clear (and non-ambiguous) answer.
Want Clear Answers to Timeframes for Martial Arts Progress?
- How Long Does It Take to Get a Black Belt? (average time and ranges)
- For Beginners: How long does it take to learn the basics of a martial art?
- Mastery: How long does it take to master a martial art?
What are your views on the black belt question? Let me know in the comments section.